Government As If People Mattered

One of my favorite subtitles ever is from a book by E. F. Shumaker. The book is “Small Is Beautiful” and the subtitle is “economics as if people mattered”. 

Today, As Mitch McConnell goes for the slam dunk on healthcare “reform” after trying so many times,  I wonder if he’s playing the right game. Mitch, like Donald Trump, is playing “Power Politics” — with the goal being, “Can I make people do my will?” Or “Let me show you who’s in charge”. Power politics is a display of power, and it is a game that comes with lucrative contracts and endorsement deals between the professionals that play it. The game doesn’t require anyone but the pros to play it. There need be no audience for the spectacle. In fact the teams would prefer there not be an audience.

I’d much rather see a game of “democracy”, which is an audience participation sport, with people in the stands getting on and off the court. In democracy, the point is to take care of the most people, allowing them to have “life”, then letting them decide what liberty and the pursuit of happiness looks like, all the while either playing by the honor system or having refs enforce the rules so that nobody gets injured or killed. 

Today, the Democrats put out a new concept/branding thing, called “A Better Deal”, which I understand calls for the government to actually police Wall Street, and not rely on it so heavily for support. The positive to this? Democracy needs referees. The bad news? They are saying that they weren’t doing their job before, and they were complicit in creating the wealth divide in this country. Well, confession is good for the soul, I guess, but they are not saying anything we didn’t already knew.

That means that what we’ve had is one party interested in telling us what to do, breeding fear and mistrust and the other party looking the other way, protecting the interests of those who have money. Does anyone in this picture appear to be looking out for 90% of the American people? No. Why do they feel helpless, like no one represents them? Because they are and no one does … at least not yet. 

So, let’s start the other way. 90% of the people have 90% of the votes, and get 90% of the representation. Bills passed should be about them 90% of the time.

What do they need or want?

1) Food. No American should go to bed hungry, or malnourished.

2) Clothing. People should be able to afford clothing that fits their circumstances.

3) Shelter. No American should freeze to death, or die of the heat. They should have a place to rest/sleep, a place to use the bathroom, store their belongings and simply be.

4) Meaning in their lives and someplace to go during the day where they can connect with others. Simply put, they need work to do, and jobs to go to. Since society is created by humans for humans, we need to make choices that include them. Automate? Replace waitresses, cashiers, bankers with machines? Why, when people need jobs? Any job that can be done by humans ought to be done by humans. When everyone who needs a job has one, then we can automate.

5) A system that takes care of people when bad things happen to them or gives them help when they need it. This means healthcare when they get sick, but it also means things like helping them participate in life — being accessible for all people. 

6) A knowledge of the law and constitution, so that they can participate in the making of rules that impact their lives. Every citizen should have a copy of the US Constitution in the language they understand. Every American should take a civics class so they know how the system works now and be empowered to make rules that work for them.

There are other things that the government should do, certainly. Education comes to mind. But let’s strive for the things above — especially the first three — and work out the details from there.

Will it take a lot of work? Oh, yeah, it will. 

Right now, 

1) corporate America wants us to/ believes we want processed foods, 

2) The clothing/fashion industry robs all ends of the process of making and buying clothes by using sweatshops to make clothes cheaply and then charging exorbitant prices for a brand.

3) People see housing as an investment rather than as a place to live.

4) People get their information via technology rather than from each other. The technology isolates us, and helps us fear each other. Actually being together will fix any irrational fear we might have. Doing something with our time — making something, doing something, helping someone — allows us to feel like we matter.

5) Death is a part of life, but people now want to force others to do it, while they live longer and use more resources. That’s “power”, not democracy. 

6) The people who live under the rules are often the people who don’t know what the rules are, leaving those in power to make the rules for others, not themselves. Those who believe in the rule of law need lawyers to do so. Right now, lawyers look for weaknesses in the system and help the powerful avoid the rule of law. They get rewarded well for doing this. 

So governing like people matters will require a great change to our hearts and minds, and we will have to take on corporations, greedy individuals, people who like power and glitz, food corporations, the fashion industry, and the legal establishment, technology companies, the stock market, and those who push us to remain ignorant of how things work. The fact that we have to work so hard is a testament to how far off of having a democracy we are. Still, I think we need to try.

Resisting with Peace,

“Roots People”

It’s Rick Fowler’s birthday, and the Anniversary of the late Rev. Benny Claytor and his late wife, Prophetess Gerry Claytor. My friend Pete Allen said of Rick and Me , “Long lost twins, separated at birth?” and it got me to thinking. Yes, Rick and I are kin, just as Charlie Crook was my “brother from another mother”.  What is it that these people all have in common in my eyes?  The are “roots music people”. Let me explain.

 Rick and I talked about another classmate/friend who — because she was honest enough to say she believed in gay rights and women’s ordination — never got ordained. After a few tries, she gave up. Rick said, through his carmudgeon face, “isn’t that sad?”. And look who did get ordained… he spoke of a pastor who was ordained and powerful who maintained his standing despite professional misconduct. I know of a few myself, and I know people who didn’t/couldn’t because they weren’t powerful or pretty enough or who didn’t hang with the right crowd. 

The people I mentioned: Rick, Benny and Gerry,  Charlie, our unordained colleague , and others have one thing in common: they know right and wrong and  try to live by it, all they while knowing via their experience that it doesn’t always matter to the world.  They don’t care. It matters to them. It’s their true soul and they couldn’t be anything else.

My types of music are just like that: simple, honest, passionate, and not particularly polished.  By that, I mean blues, country, reggae, folk and — oddly, punk. For instance, blues –with the musical notes E A GE — were an entire career for Muddy Waters. Country is stories about real life people. Reggae? Get in the groove and stay there for hours. Folk? Listen to early Bob Dylan at the Newport Folk Festival, playing one guitar chord while singing with Joan Baez. Punk? Early punk isn’t music. It’s angry guys playing the same power chords as fast as they can.. 

Each of these people, had, in the words of John Lee Hooker, something “in ’em, and it’s got to get out”. They didn’t have the money yet to play “correctly” , but it was in ’em and had to come out. Benny’s preaching and Gerry’s healing were like that. The contrast between what they knew should be and their life experience was created passion/expression. Benny was an engineer who originally couldn’t find a church building that treated him with dignity. Gerry was an educator who saw kids growing up with toxins in their schools, and later hungry people who needed to be fed and — without complaint, because the work had to be done, did the work. Charlie grew up in a town made briefly famous by a woman gang raped on a pinball machine in a bar. Charlie played guitar in church and I never once heard him complain about his life. Rick fixes cars because they make sense to him and well… people need to get their cars fixed. Our colleague gives her time to a church in a tough part of Boston. Her mother lost her house because of Bernie Madoff’s scam.

Each of the people I listed are brilliant (or above average, at least) in their own ways. Rick has an incredible theological vocabulary. Benny was smart — being an engineer is not a job for slouches. Gerry knew politics and politicians, and the value of love. Charlie could read an entire Stephen King novel in two days, while keeping up his theological studies. Our friend made it through 3 years of grad school, took care of her mother for years, and knows etiquette very well. Me? I pray nightly.  None of us has a particularly high tolerance for hate or the BS that passes for decorum. They do the things that have to get done for people nobody else cares about. The things they do for others are simple and monotonous, but they are recognized by people of all stripes as being good. 

All of the people I had lunch with last time I was in Boston are roots people like that.  Though they didn’t all know each other, I knew they would get along … and they did because they have good, simple and kind hearts, blended with a brain that won’t quit in a world that wants a fabulous show.

Lately, I have been following politics, and I guess I see “roots” in one particular woman: Maxine Waters. It was she that came out of an important meeting and said “the attorney general (or maybe FBI director) has no credibility”. It was she who stood up for Meghan Riley when the future-and-President was sexist.  She reminds me of a “church mother” and seminary friend. 
While I’m here, let me say that none of them are against decorum or law or a really good Classical music piece. We just call them kindness, justice, and good music. Meanwhile, we drone on, doing what has to be done in our own little way. We love beauty. We love intellect, we appreciate it in others, but “clever spin” does us no good. Over the years, we’ve picked up a few notes now and then. We can appreciate them and the dexterity it takes to do the things that society would like. When society gives us time enough, we’ll get there, too. Until then, we’ll try to do what is good. “And what does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. ”

Resisting with Peace, 

What Progressives Are For

I was listening to a Nation Podcast featuring an interview with Naomi Klein, who’s written a book called “No Is Not Enough” where she says that the current Democratic Party is its own worst enemy, and the reason we have been on the slippery slope to Donald Trump  for such a long time. In essence, she seems to say Democrats are asking the wrong questions or not asking the right questions. It’s not enough to be against President Trump’s agenda. We spend enough time being against their rules. As someone who is definitely not a jock, but am still proudly using a man’s brain, I’m going to use a sports metaphor: we must control the tempo of the game. We must make them play our game. Of course, we need to figure out what our game is. 

So here’s what at least this progressive is for.

I’m for equal rights. Forget being against racism, sexism, homophobia/heterosexist. I am for all people having equal rights and equal access to things.

I believe that men can be trusted, that women can be trusted, that everyone between those two poles can be trusted, to make decisions affecting their lives. I believe we should let them do so. 

I believe that there are competent Blacks, Whites, and every color (or mix) of people, and that they are are worthy of our time as a society.  I believe that all people can be more intelligent, more competent, and bigger dreamers with an education that serves their needs. I believe that they should have access to that, so that they can be their best selves.

I believe that science is true, if not totally complete, knowledge. I believe that science needs to be paired with morality or ethics in order to be of use to us as humans. 

I believe in God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit. I believe that this is compatible with belief in science, reality, and what our senses can tell us. I believe that without them, all of the knowledge in the world is of less use, and with them, we can be our best self. In fact, I believe that the Trinity calls us to be our best self.

I believe that all people should be able to meet their basic needs. If they can’t –and the reality is that some people can’t, not won’t —  I believe that society should see that they do. 

I believe that if we do all of this, we will have the peace and security we long for. 

I believe that there are limits to what people need, and that there should be limits to what they want, as well. I believe that if we share what we have, we can take care of all people. If that is not true, then — using logic and our best sense — we can figure something else out. I believe we have to try first, though.

I believe that climate change is real. I believe that we need to fix it, and we need to use our best guesses to do that. I believe we need to use the information we already have as a start.  

I like the Constitution. I especially like the preamble to it. I believe in the freedom of the press to tell us the truth about the world we live in. I also believe that the press, like all institutions, should act ethically. I believe that the bigger an institution is, the more it needs to act ethically. 

I believe that individuals sometimes act unethically. When they do, they should be stopped, and I believe they should be given a means to redeem themselves. If they don’t want to, they should be kept away from society. 

I believe that human beings are worth more than money. 

I believe that we are dependent on the environment. It is incumbent on us, therefore, to take care of it, not the least because of that dependence.

I believe that it’s none of my business whom you love, unless someone’s getting hurt in the relationship.

That’s what this progressive believes, and — if I have learned nothing else in my time blogging — I believe that I’m not alone in believing in these things.

Resisting with Peace,


People Who Don’t Like Humanity Shouldn’t Be President.

Today, my friend Val shared an article on Facebook about our President planning to/wanting to cut back on heating assistance to the old and poor. After apparently disliking half the population (see Meghan Kelly, Mika Breszinski, Hillary Clinton) adding in another 5% for Black men (see Barack Obama and Jeff Sessions)  another who-knows-how many-handicapped or sick people, (the healthcare bill) children who want to be educated in the public schools,( see also Betsy Devos) and everyone who lives on the planet (see the Paris accords on climate change), I am not surprised at all that he wants to defund heating for those who might freeze to death.

The Press tries to psychoanalize him, but it seems clear to me that — actual diagnosis aside — Donald Trump simply hates humanity. One could make the case that he likes rich, White guys, but the Paris accord decision takes them off the board as well. That leaves no one the President cares about. It’s probably not in the Constitution, but shouldn’t “crimes against humanity” be an impeachable offense? 

His politics, his words, his actions all point to hatred for the very human race that he is a part of. I don’t worry that it means he’s suicidal, because, though tragic, that would only mean one life gone. Homicidality to all human life is my first concern. After them, we can get back to him.

If this seems over-dramatic, consider his provocation of a certain Korean psychopath who is testing missiles. This does not mean, by the way, that Kim Jong Il isn’t dangerous and provocative all on his own. He is. Teasing a crazy man who is waving around a knife, however, doesn’t seem too bright to me. When the “knife” in question is a nuke… well, wow. Just wow.

So, from a scientific, experimental viewpoint, we can sit around and see if I’m right, or we can impeach him/jail him.  All the evidence says I’m right so far. If it is a sociological experiment, remember that Trump and his ilk don’t believe in science or facts, so he won’t believe whatever we say. This is a problem. Like all people who are like this, I don’t vote for the death penalty in whatever form, but I do believe in restraint until he can be safe with others. Right now, President is not showing any signs in that direction. I would settle for impeachment, but would prefer time in a psychological treatment facility until that changes.

Yes, it is that bad.
Resisting with Peace,

Links To The Other Beautiful America

On this 4th of July, my two blogs, “Like It Matters” and “Because It Matters” have reached a total of 20,000 hits!. It is my pleasure to talk about people I have written about in the 6 years of blogging. I do that in depth in the simultaneously posted “Because It Matters” Post “The Other Beautiful America ”  In this article, I’m posting the links to  the organizations, artists, etc. None of this is paid advertising. They are just good people I thought you should know about.


The UCC and Connecticut Conference, UCC

The American Baptist Churches USA

American Baptists CT

Presbyterian Church USA

Society of Friends/Quakers

Friends Service Committee

United Methodists


Todd’s Church in Hampden, MA

Beneficent UCC, Providence, RI

John Hudson’s Church , Sherborn, MA

Lisa’s church, Winsted, CT

Ken Ferguson’s church, Central Village, CT

Eric Anderson’s UCC Church, Hilo, Hawaii



Silver Lake , CT

Camp Wightman, CT

Skye Farm, NY

CYC (Christian Youth Conference), Maine


Pat Speer’s Group — Christian Activities Council

Lesbian who saved a congressman’s life

Pulse Nightclub Community

South Church and Recapture Healing

True Colors, Hartford


Bee’s church

Patricia Ginyard’s Group

Kevin Ginyard’s Church

Church of God In Christ

Black Lives Matter

Jeff Brown’s organization

Jeff’s church

Jeff’s TED Talk

Feed The People Food Pantry

Geraldine Claytor Magnet Academy

Boys and Girls Club, Rochester, NY

Beyond The Moment


American Civil Liberties Union

National Organization For Women

National Coalition Builder’s Institute

Alcoholics Anonymous

Save The Children



Cunningham Tire of Reading



Liz’s College

Bobbie Fox at Manchester Community College

Charter Oak Global Academy

West Hartford Schools: Sedgewick and Conard



Where Mar (used to?) work(s)

Baystate Hospital

Shriner’s Hospital

River Valley Counseling

Petaluma People’s Services, Petaluma, CA

Formerly South Bay Mental Health…

Child Guidance Clinic, Springfield, MA

Hartford Hospital’s Institute For Living

Virginia Satir Global Network



Beebs and Her Money Makers

Joan Osborne

The Harry Chapin Foundation

Jen Chapin

Tom Chapin

Steve Chapin, Big John Wallace and Howie Fields

The Chapin Family

The Chapin Sisters

An old article on Larry Baker (more to come)

99 seat theaters in LA

Rant and Rave/Rogue Machine




What Washington Doesn’t Get… 

I’ve been listening to Morning  Joe lately because the seem to offer balanced left/right, conservative/liberal, Democrat/Republican positions. The other day, in talking about President Trump and Healthcare, they started a sentence with “putting aside the moral issues, of which there are many….”. That’s when it hit me: That is what’s wrong here — in Washington and for those playing our home game: We think we can put aside morals and talk about politics. Politics is supposed to be about morals — our morals as a country, represented by moral people who want to do right by the country. I don’t mean piety, by the way. I don’t care who wears a flag on their lapel, or who can recite the 10 Commandments. What I care about is whether or not they live the 10 commandments in dealing with their constituents. I don’t care if you look like a patriot. I care if you are a patriot.

This most recent healthcare attempt is the closest thing I can remember to an anti-moral bill any Congressional wanted to act on in my lifetime. “Feed the rich, starve the poor” is anti-morality. .Take away people’s healthcare, while keeping your own is no way to build compassion. Put back into place laws that we know punished African-Americans so you can prove you’re “tough on crime”? Moses freed slaves. He didn’t make more of them. Cutting back on food for kids or adults while giving more to those who have plenty

Of the three “inalienable rights”, those who fight for “liberty and the pursuit of happiness” have forgotten those who fight for “life”. While chasing what life “looks like to others”, they have forgotten that what life IS is reality. While they live in illusion, it’s reality that will get them. Scoring points against “The Other Side”, whichever side you’re on, is NOT the goal.  Serving others is.  When our public servants understand  that, things will change. Until then, nothing will. 

Misunderstood Love — Leaders in the Church

Since I was a kid, I have seen God as a picture in a comic book. What we now call “pixels”, I just called “dots”, but it is still my understanding of God. Ok, not God exactly, but our picture of God. The church, the earth’s people, gathered in community together each know a bit of God. Each of those people is one dot in our picture of God. The more people, the more dots, the clearer the picture that we can get of who God is, and maybe where God is taking us. Each of those dots are different. There are green ones, there are red ones, there are strong black ones that form an outline somehow. There are white ones that open up space, and so on, in our picture of God.

This afternoon, my wife and I had the opportunity to attend the Authorized Ministers Lunch and Gathering for the states — Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island. Most of the people there were clergy, but there some former parishioners in the audience as well. There were colleagues and friends that I had known for years, and a few surprises. Two people that I know were celebrating their 25th anniversary of ordination. More about them later, but for now, here was my conflict: the people in parishes and people outside of parishes I know think the people in that meeting are somehow mean to them — making them do this or that. The people in the Luncheon, combined, don’t have a mean bone in their bodies . Not a one of them wants to hurt the world in any way. They are all different, but honestly, the one thing they have in common is kindness to the world and the people in it. 

Let me give you examples:

In a room full of 300 people or so, I knew a bunch of them.

At my table: 

Susie Townsley ,  gracious, organized, lived in Japan for years.

John Hudson, worker, loves to work with camps and campers to transform the world.

Scott Morrow, a businessman of a pastor, composed, determined and kind.

MIchelle Madsen-Bibeau, perhaps the most administrative person I know, lots of stamina, loves visiting with people.

Around the room: 

Jane Rowe, my local pastor, warm and kind as a mother figure, an educator

Matt McCaffrey, humorous, musical, pastoral, and sneakily administrative.

Tamara Moreland, pastoral, kind, working grit, and a church mother.

Michael Ciba, quiet, a bit nerdy, a family man.

Evelyn Eddy, compassionate, kind, wise in her bones through experience no one would want. Also literate and magical.

Paul Bryant-Smith, quiet, musical, a chaplain

Lucille Fritz, funny, kind, loveable, joyous.

Janet Stoddard, kind, warm, a chaplain who simply cares for a living.

Barbara Libby, a smiling, grace-filled gardener.

George Harris, gregarious and kind, a nicer guy you’re not likely to meet.

Kent Siladi, a teddy bear in a business suit.

Sioux Wilusz, intense, but soft spoken

Wendy VanderHart, intense, styling, and serious, fun in her own way.

But congregants and outsiders think… 

They’re radical!

They’re judgemental!

They’re pushing the gay agenda! 

They’re not patriotic! 

They may not even be Christian!

They don’t believe in Right-And-Wrong, they believe in feelings!

They are taking us places we don’t want to go!

They hate America! 

But mostly, “They’re making us change and do stuff we don’t want to do”, and some version of “They like weirdos better than us traditional “normal” people”. 

If there was one thing I want people to know, it’s this: Nothing they do comes from hate. It comes from love. It comes from a unique call to follow a God as best they can. Yes, some of them like (or prefer, or work with) “weirdos”, but that’s because “normal” folks don’t, and they are convinced that God wants us to include their dots to our picture of God. 

If you’re afraid of liberals, or angry at liberals, or feel judged by ministers, remember this: Kind and loving people can’t take you anywhere bad. People who love the world and want to make it better are not trying to hurt you. God, at least as drawn by these “dots”, wants you to see how wonderful the world can be for everybody. They want to take you places you want to go.

Further, if you think they’re different than you, or you’re different from them, they are all different from each other!  The one thing they have in common is love that comes from God.  How can that be bad thing? It can’t. 
Resisting with Peace ,